Early placement decisions have lasting consequences for siblings in care, new research shows

The Government’s Enduring Relationships policy provides a welcome shift toward recognising the lifelong significance of connections for children in care across policy and practice. But if the Government want to realise its ambitions for enduring sibling relationships, the focus must be on getting sibling decisions right from the outset, according to new research by the University of Bristol.

Using local authority administrative data tracking the placements of 544 children and their siblings over time, alongside interviews with social work professionals and case file analysis in two local authorities, the research found that whether siblings remained together or apart was largely determined at the point of first entry into care and by the length of time spent in care.

Siblings who were placed together from the outset were likely to stay together, while siblings who were separated at the outset were rarely reunited in later living arrangements. Children with shorter stays in care were more likely to remain with at least one sibling. Among children with longer stays two distinct patterns emerged; some remained together most of their time in care, while others, despite having lived together for an extended period, were still separated after around 2.5 years.

The research highlights the crucial importance of early decision making in determining whether siblings remain together or apart, but also emphasises the need for ongoing support for siblings that spend longer in care as well as better recording of early decision making for siblings entering the care system.

“By using data from two local authorities, we found that 75% of children in our sample were initially placed with at least one sibling. That’s an interesting, and perhaps encouraging, starting point. But we need to be careful not to assume that the picture is the same across the country.

As the recent Children’s Commissioner report and the most recent APPG inquiry have highlighted, we need better national evidence. We also need to look beyond the point at which children enter care and understand how decisions about siblings living together or apart evolve over time. This means building a clearer picture of why some children are not placed with siblings from the outset, why others are separated later, and whether those decisions are appropriate and reviewed as children’s circumstances, needs and wishes change over time. Not only by creating this evidence, but also by bringing people together through a newly initiated Community of Practice on Siblings in Care, we would be able to identify where practice could be improved and how decisions about siblings living together or apart, and the relationships that matter to them, could be better supported.” Dr Florie Schmits, ESRC Postdoctoral fellow University of Exeter (who undertook this research at the University of Bristol). 

“This important policy briefing highlights that, once siblings are separated, they are rarely reunited, making these early decisions particularly significant for children and their future relationships. It reinforces the need for great care when determining whether siblings should live together or apart, recognising the lasting impact these decisions can have on children’s identity, relationships and experiences.”

“The research also found that the reasons behind these decisions were not always clearly documented. Care-experienced people have consistently highlighted the importance of having access to coherent and comprehensive information about their history and life events. When such consequential decisions are made, we have a duty to ensure that the rationale is clearly recorded and available to children in the future. We look forward to working with Dr Schmits in the new year to establish a new Community of Practice focused on supporting sibling relationships.” James Bury, Managing Director of Policy Research and Development, CoramBAAF

The findings suggest that opportunities to shape sibling relationships are greatest when children first enter care. Early identification of sibling relationships, accurate recording of who matters to children, and decision-making at the outset has a lasting impact on sibling’s long-term experiences in care. While ongoing support, and reasonable contact remains important, the research highlights how the foundations for enduring sibling relationships are often laid at the earliest contact with the care system.

Alongside these findings, the policy paper sets out 15 recommendations for policy and practice designed to strengthen sibling relationships for children in care. The recommendations are grouped across four key areas: recognising and understanding sibling relationships; rethinking decisions that affect whether siblings can remain together; supporting the professionals and carers who help sustain sibling relationships; and improving the recording and evidence available about siblings in care.