Selected dissertation abstracts relating to education in the following small states
- Aminath Shiyama, PhD 2020
- Terra Sprague, PhD 2019
- Karen Ione Best, EdD 2019
- Rhonda DiBiase, PhD 2016
- Aminath Muna, EdD 2014
- Michele Mills, PhD 2013
- Guy le Fanu, EdD 2011
- Abdulla Zameer, EdD 2010
- Beatrice Fulford, EdD 2008
- Terra Sprague, MEd 2008
- Harris Hadjithemistos, MEd 2008
- Herbert Fulford, EdD 2008
- Nkobi Owen Pansiri, EdD 2008
- Graham Fisher, PhD 2004
- Mark James, PhD 2003
- George Bristol, MEd 2003
- Keith Holmes, PhD 2002
- Willy Yamuna Ako, EdD 2002
- Glynn Galo, EdD 2001
- Thomas Kuli Webster, EdD 1997
- Akhila Nand Sharma, EdD 1995
- Gabatshwane Taka Tsayang, EdD 1995
- Calliopa Pearlette Louisy, PhD 1993
Primary teacher professional learning in the Maldives: An explorative study of science process skills pedagogies
Aminath Shiyama, PhD 2020, School of Education, University of Bristol
The teaching of science process skills (SPS), such as observing, measuring, hypothesising, and investigating, are integral to school science education and with constructivist pedagogies, those SPS can be taught with contextual contingencies. This study is focussed on the context of upper primary schools in the Maldives, where science is taught by generalist teachers. The aim of this study was to work in collaboration with those teachers to explore a contextually contingent approach to teach SPS in upper primary schools. The collaboration, informed by social learning theories, was designed as a form of continuing teacher professional development that allowed insights into teachers’ professional learning for teaching
SPS. Hence, exploring SPS pedagogies and teacher professional learning in tandem offers a nuanced view into the contextual contingencies of these practices.
An epistemological view of social-constructivism was adopted to explore the intricate and subjective processes of teacher learning. A participatory teacher research methodology comprising two phases of data collection and analysis was adopted as the research methodology. In the first phase, interview data from 14 generalist primary teachers was used to identify widespread practices of SPS pedagogies and teacher professional development. Focus group interviews with teacher educators and curriculum developers provided contextualisation for these practices. Findings from the first phase informed development of the second phase of data collection. The second phase engaged four generalist primary teachers in professional learning activities over a period of six months; the intervention focussed on the planning and implementing of inquiry-based investigation approaches as a form of SPS pedagogies. Acting as both professional learning facilitator and researcher, I gathered data through individual interviews, classroom observations, and group meetings; supplementing them with our co-developed teaching resources, and teacher-led classroom-based research inquiry. For this phase, narrative, thematic data analysis was conducted and combined with findings from the first phase, which provided a richly textured and complex picture of SPS pedagogies and teacher professional learning.
When generalist teachers instruct science classes, the SPS pedagogies that they can practice are variations of formalist pedagogies and progressive constructivist approaches. These seemingly opposite teaching strategies create tension between the enactment and experiences of the SPS pedagogies prescribed in the curriculum. Further, applying a social learning lens to teacher professional learning offers a contextually-situated understanding of the micro-processes and the micro-dynamics of teachers’ learning, pedagogical praxis, professionalism, and the incessant challenges in teaching outside of one’s specialism. These findings add to the existing empirical base that argues against ‘one-size-fits-all’ educational practices that are emblematic of uncritical borrowing in global education. Thus, this study highlights that SPS needs to be flexibly defined and taught as an integrated set of skills which are applied in learning the content of science using contextually sensitive pedagogies. In order to support generalists who are teaching science outside of their specialism, professional learning that is centred on their classroom is critical. Additionally, this study emphasises the importance of contextually contingent practices of professional development and pedagogical praxis; an approach that allows for flexibility and differentiation in teacher learning. Finally, this study highlights the crucial role of local researchers in bringing contextual realities and sensitivities to the forefront of comparative research.
Terra Sprague, PhD 2019, School of Sociology, Politics and International Studies, University of Bristol
The old story of humanity’s relationship with planet Earth, one characterised by domination, disposability and inattention to equilibrium, no longer serves us. Humanity needs a New Story about its relationship with the Earth for the age of the Anthropocene in order to cultivate responses to environmental change which are not rooted in fear. This thesis contributes to the project of writing that New Story through a narrative inquiry into the concerns and responses of islanders from Fiji, Mauritius and St Lucia to their changing environmental conditions.
Grounded in Deleuze’s concepts of multiplicity, the rhizome and mapping, the thesis draws further inspiration from Pacific Island concepts of Sokota (voyaging) and Talanoa (dialogic inquiry) methodology. The narrative analysis brings together the contributions of a range of participants, gathered over the course of six site visits to Fiji, Mauritius and St Lucia, by creating a set of conversations within a metaphorical mangrove forest. This mangrove forest represents the multiplicity of local perspectives in these islands and becomes the site of conversation and story-telling. As such, it becomes a literary tool through which the inquiry’s participants, who are otherwise mostly unknown to each other, are connected on the page through sharing folktales and discussion of current experiences and offering insights and messages to others.
The conversations answer three primary questions: what are the pressing environmental concerns in these island nations; what have been some of the responses to those concerns; and, what are the messages that islanders wish to convey to themselves and others regarding what actions need taking. Through these conversations, a number of themes arise, including trust in nature, resisting fear, identifying barriers to resilience, citizen led responses to environmental issues and an approach to blending different knowledges for strengthened responses.
As well as contributing elements of a New Story of humanity’s relationship with the Earth, the thesis offers a methodological contribution to the global pursuit of that New Story. It first listens to a multiplicity of perspectives, then engages in conversations before going deeper to acknowledge that matters of human equity underpin today’s environmental issues. It builds and presents its analysis using metaphor and through constructing dialogue in order to blend different knowledges. It argues that the development of a New Story about humanity’s relationship with the Earth is one that must be collectively written and shared in order to meet the environmental challenges of this day, and that narrative inquiry can help us to do this.
Gauging Stakeholders Perceptions on Policy Shifts in the Financing of Tertiary Education at the University of the West Indies - Cave Hill Campus, Barbados
Karen Ione Best, EdD 2019, University of Sheffield
My study sought to gauge stakeholders’ perceptions of policy shifts in the financing of tertiary education at the University of the West Indies - Cave Hill Campus, Barbados. The financing of tertiary education in Barbados has been borne by the government since 1966 with zero cost to the student. In September 2014, the government of Barbados introduced a 20% tuition fee paid by the student with the government paying the remaining 80% of the economic cost. The study employed individual and focus group interviews to determine the perceptions of the various categories of stakeholders on financing tertiary education at the University of the West Indies (UWI) Barbados. The research also documented the views of the stakeholders on alternative models of financing tertiary education for the university. The findings indicate that the stakeholders felt that the public financing of tertiary education resulted in the political, social and national development of the country while it also contributed to the increase in public expenditure. In response to the change in public funding, the participants felt that the new model could reduce the public expenditure but it could also have the potential to reduce the access to persons from the lower socio-economic strata. The stakeholders suggested alternative models with the mixed model of financing being the one most supported. Finally, based on the data emerging from the study, there is a need for a larger and more detailed evaluation of the current model of financing tertiary education because of its impact on access, sustainable financing for tertiary education and further research.
Investigating Active Learning Reform in The Small State of the Maldives: What works and under what circumstances?
Rhonda DiBiase, PhD 2016, Melbourne Graduate School of Education, The University of Melbourne
Globally, national governments and donor organisations have endorsed pedagogical reform in their efforts to improve the quality of education, yet disparity between policy and practice is well-documented. In the small state of the Maldives, UNICEF supported Child Friendly School’s project and the new National Curriculum both endorse active learning pedagogy, but implementation challenges have been widely acknowledged. The aim of this qualitative study was to investigate how teachers can enact active learning pedagogy in the Maldivian education system. It was conceived using design-based research, an interventionist methodology, which examines the conditions that influence how educational innovations work in real-life practice. The study was situated in an island school selected for offering optimum conditions for implementation of the pedagogical intervention, and was conducted over two phases: a contextual analysis phase; and an intervention phase.
Using an adaptation of the World Café (J. Brown & Isaacs, 2005), a participatory approach to data collection, the contextual analysis was undertaken with members of the school community — parents, teachers and school leadership — to identify local priorities and perspectives of active learning. The results from this phase revealed features of active learning considered important in the school community: the active participation of students; the use of group work to aid learning; emphasis on the role of teacher as facilitator; the necessity for a friendly classroom environment; and the potential of active learning to cater more equally for all students. Embracing these features of active learning, a pedagogical intervention was developed in collaboration with teachers and school management, to support teachers’ enactment of active learning in the school. The intervention, an instructional model, was then enacted in the island school with two groups of primary teachers and studied over eight months. Data on the teachers’ use of the instructional model were collected through multiple sources that included, teacher recording booklets, questionnaires, interviews and classroom observations.
The data revealed the factors that both supported and inhibited teachers’ use of the intervention. These were converted into design principles; an anticipated outcome of design-based research, highlighting three broad areas that revealed what worked in what circumstances, and represented the study’s key findings identifying the need to: develop a contextually relevant model of active learning that respects local priorities, fits with the circumstances of teachers’ work, and takes into account the available resources; and moves from conceptual ambiguity to operational clarity; support teachers’ knowledge-practice refinement by creating space for reform, providing on-going classroom-based support and drawing on available resources; and foster a change-welcoming school reform approach through an inclusive process that mobilises community participation.
The conceptual framework of design principles that evolved from the study can potentially guide like schools and communities engaging with reform around active learning pedagogy. It is recommended that future research explores the transferability of these design principles to other contexts.
Aminath Muna, EdD 2014, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol
Education has always been highly valued in the Maldives. Every historical document, from times ancient, testifies to the deference and respect that the learned person has received from the society. Historically, an education comprised of acquiring knowledge on the religion of Islam, which constitutes the foundations of culture and society in the country. For centuries, the purpose of education has been twofold: the proliferation and maintenance of religious knowledge in the country, and the transmission of essential skills for maritime people. The shape of the existing organized system of education began to emerge only in the latter half of the twentieth century.
The appearance of vocation-oriented postsecondary training centres has closely linked to the needs and priorities of programs for national development. The growth and amalgamation of these centres culminated in the establishment of the Maldives National University in 2011and led to the rise of private tertiary education providers.
This dissertation traces the historical progressions that led to the evolution and development of tertiary education in the Maldives within the framework of the small state’s paradigm. It investigates the economic, social and political forces that guided and steered the emergence of this sector. While many influences and trends that parallel those in other small states can be seen, some crucial differences exist. Vulnerability to climate change and the narrow economic base of the country are shared characteristics. On the other hand, the isolation of Maldives among a group of larger neighbouring states has profound implications for the development of the national university. Key issues of access, quality, governance and collaboration emerged from a detailed qualitative case study of the Maldives National University. The case study reveals the achievements, challenges and priorities of the new national university. In the light of this analysis, it is argued that there is a pressing need to strengthen tertiary education by creating a sustainable policy framework for transforming the sector to better cater for its growth, quality improvement, research profile, governance and autonomy. Unlike many small states, Maldives is isolated and consequently faces further challenges in exploiting the potential benefits of regional cooperation and alliances. This has related theoretical implications for tertiary education that are identified and that need to be explored and addressed in future studies on tertiary education in small states.
Michele Mills, Graduate School of Education-PhD (2013)
The high-stakes eleven-plus placement examination has remained a feature of the education systems of many postcolonial Anglophone Caribbean territories. Originally based on a British model, it was introduced to the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago in 1961 and was perceived to be the fairest means of allocating the limited number of secondary school places. The expansion of the secondary sector and the achievement of universal secondary education, however, have had little impact on the selection role and societal significance of the examination in the local context.
This qualitative study draws on concepts of cultural and social capital and power, and the theoretical work of sociological and educational researchers such as Bourdieu, Foucault, Bernstein, Dore and Broadfoot, to investigate whose interests are being served by maintaining the selective examination system. This is done with reference to implications that stem from the uncritical transfer of educational and assessment policies and practices to, and within, small states. More specifically, critical discourse analysis, and four detailed school case studies, are employed to examine the extent to which the Trinidad and Tobago eleven-plus reproduces patterns of power and social inequity in practice. In developing the arguments, the study draws upon experiential knowledge based on my own varied professional experience within the Trinidad education system. Metaphor informs the stages of data analysis and allows the voices of the research participants to be foregrounded in the presentation of the data. Additionally, metaphor offers an important bridge that connects the findings with the key theoretical concepts that guide the study.
The findings suggest that students are unequally positioned in terms of access to the cultural, social and linguistic capital that is taken for granted, and indeed required and rewarded, by the examination. It is argued that the linguistic and cultural competence demanded by the examination process requires initial familiarisation within the family and that those students who are better placed, in terms of the quantity and quality of such capital, have a better feel for the game and a significant advantage at the eleven-plus level. These findings are consistent with Bourdieu’s theory that education systems reproduce the unequal distribution of cultural capital and therefore contribute to the reproduction of inequities in the social structure. In concluding, it is argued that the eleven-plus examination symbolises and is located within the power struggles and ideological disconnections that marked its introduction to Trinidad and Tobago in the 1960s.
Abdulla Zameer, Graduate School of Education, EdD Student (2010)
This study offers an understanding of primary school head leadership in the Maldives, following an exploration of their perspectives and practices. More specifically, the study examines the relationship between the Head Teacher’s espoused leadership aspirations and accounts of their practice, what these practices are in reality, and asks the question, ‘What are the implications for ‘leadership’ when espoused theories and headship actions do not coincide?’
This study, the first of its kind on primary school head leadership in the Maldives, employs a qualitative approach. It uses biographical data and semi-structured interviews to understand the meanings school principals attribute to leadership, their actions, and the dilemmas they face as they operate in the public schooling sector. I also draw upon documentary evidence from school logs, school handbooks, personal diaries and memos.
The findings reveal that the principals readily associate leadership with concepts and theories of leadership that are prevalent in contemporary literature on educational management and leadership. These concepts include a sense of vision and goals, engaging the emotions of individuals in the organisation, involving others through a participative approach, relationship building, and responding to the challenges arising from the context. However, the data suggests that the Primary School Heads do not engage themselves in the perceived definitions of leadership. Rather, their definitions and concepts of leadership are largely rhetorical and barely deployed in practice.
It is argued in this thesis that the gap between their philosophical understandings and pragmatic reality is largely a product of the context that confines their practices to the particular social-political setting they are placed in. The role of school head is structured by more managerial modes of engagement imposed on them, so that their leadership actions are not guided by strong democratic principles based on a personal philosophy or a theoretical foundation expressed in literature. Instead, their practices tend towards fragmented, dysfunctional engagements as part of their bureaucratic obligations, stakeholder’s expectations, and personal goals and aspirations.
In conclusion, this study raises concerns over the quality of their leadership and its implications for schools in the local context. Several suggestions are put forward in this study for training and to improve policy practised in terms of school leadership in the Maldives.
Guy le Fanu, Graduate School of Education, EdD Student (2011)
Guy's doctoral research focuses on the implementation of the new national curriculum in Papua New Guinea, a curriculum which is intended to promote inclusive education for students who at present are either marginalised within the education system or excluded from the education system altogether. The research explores the extent to which the new curriculum is being implemented in schools and the various factors explaining its implementation/ non-implementation. His research not only involves documentary analysis but carrying out a case study of two rural primary schools in the Eastern Highlands. The primary purpose of the research is to identify the barriers to and opportunities for inclusive education in Papua New Guinea and other developing countries, and to identify ways in which governments and international development organisation can overcome these barriers and make best use of these opportunities. However, the research also seeks to identify ways in which ethnographers can sensitively, insightfully and ethically research complex and unfamiliar social worlds.
Beatrice Louise Fulford, Graduate School of Education, EdD Student (2008)
Globally, education systems are threatened by teacher shortages at a time when the demand for teachers is steadily increasing, and expectations of improved quality in education delivery and outcomes are higher than ever. This has repercussions for small states that are already challenged by scarce human resources. A country's inability to provide a steady supply of appropriately trained and experienced teachers threatens not only its education sector, but also the sustainability of its social and economic development.
In the light of insights derived from the related theoretical literature, this study seeks to identify those factors that impact upon teacher recruitment and retention in the Turks & Caicos Islands (TCI), a UK Overseas Territory. The study largely adopts the methodological orientation of the interpretive/hermeneutic paradigm, but employs both qualitative and quantitative approaches to data collection. These are supplemented by a review of primary and secondary source documents. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with a cross section of education personnel and students within the TCI. A purpose-built questionnaire was also administered to teachers who had served in the TCI Teaching Service (TCITS), but had left, or were about to leave.
The findings suggest that, locally, many young school leavers are not attracted to teaching because the profession currently suffers from al loss of prestige, student indiscipline, and low salaries and other disincentives. The findings also suggest that teachers are not being retained at satisfactory rates due to unfavourable teachers' personal circumstances, a poor image of the profession, lack of training and professional development opportunities, limited involvement in decision-making processes, challenges with school leadership and other staff relations, and student indiscipline. Collectively, these make teaching unappealing and challenge teacher recruitment and retention policies and practices.
Simultaneously, opportunities in more appealing and lucrative professional fields are expanding, and are attracting the kind of knowledge, skills and attitudes that teachers possess. The findings also draw attention to the negative impact that the departure of teachers from the classroom has on students' learning and overall development.
The research has distinctive implications for policy and practice in the Turks & Caicos Islands and other small states. These implications, and those for the related theoretical literature, for capacity building in small states, and for future research are explored in the conclusions.
Terra L Sprague, Graduate School of Education, MEd Student (2008)
In a rapidly changing educational setting influenced by global and economic forces, the small transitional state of Armenia is implementing changes to its pupil assessment policy, including the introduction of a Unified School-leaving and University-entrance Examination. This holistic, qualitative study investigates the Unified Examination Policy through the lens of teachers of English as a Foreign Language by seeking to identify their perceptions and understandings of this new policy, as implemented during the 2007-2008 academic year.
The study includes a theoretical literature review, critical documentary analysis and empirical fieldwork carried out in Armenia. The fieldwork component consists of observation, semi-structured interviews and a focus group. These dimensions involve a total of ten teachers and 11 additional stakeholders. The study additionally benefits from the author's experiential knowledge gained from three years of professional work in Armenia as a teacher trainer.
The findings show that, while teachers share a positive opinion of the new Unified Examination Policy, they feel the pressure of heightened stakes and there is early evidence of backwash effects of examination standardisation which have significant cultural implications. The findings also reveal internal contradictions within the Unified Examination Policy and external contradictions between this and other current education policies in Armenia. Conflict between small states and transitional states contexts is highlighted, bringing an interesting dimension to the study and offering lessons for policy makers.
Conclusions both support and challenge existing theoretical literature relating to large-scale, high-stakes examinations and small states. Future research that builds upon the study could help to better understand the backwash effects of the new Unified Examination and to assess to what extent it may impact upon Armenia's group culture and oral heritage.
Harris Hadjithemistos, Graduate School of Education, MEd Student (2008)
This study investigates the case of the small state of Cyprus relating to the debates about education and identity in a globalised world. It argues that incorporating global values and agendas into the local education system might prove dangerous for the well grounded national identity of the island and the culture of its people. However, it further argues that learning from various other sources and mobilising local resources, knowledge and expertise can help the island mediate external pressures and interventions and achieve change that is best suited to its cultural realities and conditions.
Human resource management and staff performance appraisal in small states: a case study of the Turks & Caicos Islands
Hubert Fulford, Graduate School of Education, EdD Student (2008)
This dissertation examines the impact that Human Resource Management (HRM) strategies and Staff Performance Appraisal Systems (SPAS) have on public sector organisations. The available literature suggests that, while there are strong advocates of SPAS, a number of critics also challenge such initiatives. Three bodies of international literature are reviewed to provide a theoretical framework for the study. These are related to: international and comparative research, HRM, and education and development in small states.
In the light of the literature reviews, the research adopts a multi-layered approach for a case study of the SPAS in the Public Service of the Turks & Caicos Islands (TCI). By examining recent initiatives pursued in the TCI, this study clarifies the ways in which SPAS strategies have been used to improve efficiency and effectiveness in the public service, along with the constraints that these new initiatives have encountered. The time period covered for the case study deals with the implementation of two phases of SPAS, implemented from 1993 and 2003 respectively. Two major research strategies were employed for the empirical part of the study. The first, as indicated above, was to adopt a case study framework. Secondly, a mixed methods approach to data collection was employed. Data were collected from local TCI archives, from published and un-published reports, from qualitative interviews and from questionnaires administered to senior government officials in the TCI as well as staff they supervise. Field work was also carried out in Jamaica and Saint Lucia where qualitative interviews were undertaken with senior personnel involved in HRM.
Findings suggest that SPS can be empowering instruments in human resource development, but their operation, in practice, can be both problematic and a very time consuming exercise. Moreover the study suggests that, often, staff appraisal exercises are not accorded the level of attention they deserve. This constraint is particularly evident in small states where administrators often have multifunctional roles.
Conclusions identify implications for policy and practice in the TCI, and for the theoretical literature related to HRM and educational development in small states. At the broadest level, the study cautions against the uncritical international transfer of policies and practices, and highlights the importance of HRM strategies being carefully tailored to local cultural and contextual conditions.
Nkobi Owen Pansiri, Graduate School of Education, EdD Student (2008)
Low retention in basic education in Botswana particularly in rural ethnic minority areas is a complex educational issue. This study aims at identifying dominant factors and discourses that shape the behaviour of children and their commitment towards schooling. The research is being carried out in two linked schools (primary and junior secondary) in the remote areas of the North West District in Botswana. I draw my frame of reference from theories of ethnocentrism and social reproduction. Ethnocentrism is applied to explore the place of indigenous knowledge in educational policies and practices - and how this impacts on behaviours of both parents and pupils towards schooling. Education and social reproduction, is used to explore the implications of educational policies and practices at the school level. Literature from both Western and African perspectives shows that school retention is still an unexplained educational problem. This affects children from poor families and minorities more than the rich and dominant social groups. Much literature has identified, policy related issues, in-school and out of school factors that contribute to low school retention. From the African perspective, common in-school factors are associated with perceived deficiencies in school cultures, guidance and teaching; whereas out-of-school issues relate to health, indigenous culture and the low socio-economic status of parents. Most previous studies have used traditional research methodologies focused upon attitudinal assessments of children, teachers and parents. Many studies have taken hegemonic stances in which early school leavers are criticised for their decisions to disengage from schooling. There is, however, a growing critique of such methodologies, because they do not help to generate a clear and field-based understanding of the problems of low retention. There, therefore, is a renewed call for research that accommodates the ‘voice’ of the affected children. It is argued that client-based narratives could lead to the formulation of improved evidence-based educational policy making, which may make research more relevant for practitioners and specific contexts.
Graham Fisher, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished PhD (2004)
The UK Overseas Territories face many similar development challenges to those encountered by small states: scale and isolation; economic, political, social, environmental and cultural vulnerability; the impact of rapid globalisation; the implications of information and communications technologies; and the growing importance of high skills economies. Many writers argue that if small states are to fully utilise their limited human resources to cope with these challenges, take part in any global sharing and communication of knowledge, and exercise greater control over their own destiny, then the expansion of post-compulsory education is vital. Despite the progress of the past 40 years, many small states nevertheless rely heavily upon external control and provision of post-compulsory education.
For the UK Overseas Territories these problems become more complex given their micro scale and constitutional status. The UK Government is seeking to improve local government, increase local autonomy and economic self-sufficiency and end support to the territories, at a time of falling birth rates and increased migration for some of them.
This research adopts a combination of comparative and qualitative research strategies, and draws upon literature from the fields of international and comparative education, small states research and post-compulsory education. Existing work on the Overseas Territories is reviewed and focus is placed on a critical analysis of trends in policy and practice and an exploration of the potential and limitations for post-compulsory education in these contexts. Detailed case studies of the Cayman Islands and Montserrat form the original fieldwork component of the research. Implications for future policy and practice within the territories are examined in detail and broader conclusions are drawn concerning the related theoretical and methodological literature and priorities for future research.
Mark James, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished PhD (2003)
There is a powerful international rhetoric concerned with the need for education, at present focused on the target of universal primary schooling. The quality of that schooling has, however, been a subsidiary target, often poorly defined, and in reality seldom well implemented. This study starts from the premise that this is a major weakness in the drive for Universal Primary Education, and investigates how to improve learning and teaching in low income country rural primary school systems.
An initial hypothesis is that an important route to better educated children is the quality of the evaluative activities that are used by the actors at various levels of the system. Drawing on three bodies of research literature, concerned with donor supported country systems, classroom interaction, and evaluation, this dissertation tests the theory that failure to weave insights from all three perspectives together, when formulating policies, is a root cause of poor results.
The research applies a comparative case study approach, drawing on fieldwork in the Indian State of Andhra Pradesh, The Gambia and Tanzania, where donor funded programmes are being implemented.
The methodological orientation of the study is critical/hermeneutic, and though not formally collaborative, accepts as given the aims and objectives of the programmes under study. In tune with the philosophy of illuminating what was happening in the programme, findings were shared with actors observed or interviewed. Data are qualitative, consisting of classroom observation, semi-structured interviews and local documentation.
The study’s findings apply Riddell’s (1999) concepts of programme and evaluation capacity building success. The analysis explores and compares issues within the levels of each system that support, challenge, or constrain attempts to improve teaching and learning. The findings suggest that the school improvement paradigm holds real possibilities for quality improvement if evaluative activities are developed, not on their own, but as part of improved professionalism at teacher and administrative levels.
Keith Holmes, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished PhD (2002)
In recent years, governments, development agencies and civil society organisations have prioritised education. Strengthening ‘research capacity’ is high on their agendas in the global ‘knowledge economy’. Yet, while efforts to strengthen research capacity are underway worldwide, established modalities of social and educational research are being criticised for not contributing enough to the improvement of policy and practice. Indeed, orthodox modalities of social and educational research are widely challenged for not being suited to contemporary needs in the ‘North’ or the ‘South’.
Dilemmas arising from the uncritical international transfer of educational policies and practices are well documented in the subject field of international and comparative education. The cross-cultural transfer of research agendas, methodologies and paradigms is also problematic. For example, attempts to strengthen research capacity in the South often draw uncritically upon Euro-American modalities of research. This raises questions about how knowledge for educational development is produced and whose interests are served. These questions are critically explored here through an analysis of discourses relating to knowledge for educational development and ‘research capacity’ in small states, with special reference to St Lucia in the Caribbean.
A postcolonial analytical framework is developed from two bodies of theoretical literature. The first of these relates to knowledge, development and postcolonialism. The second relates to contemporary debates about the nature and purpose of social and educational research. Consistent with a postcolonial perspective, the case study of St Lucia utilises and tests a collaborative research methodology. Data from observations, interviews, focus groups and documentary sources are analysed in the interpretative tradition. Critical perspectives and themes emerge which highlight the complex interrelationships between cultures, research capacity and knowledge for educational development. Finally, implications for social and educational research in St Lucia, the Commonwealth Caribbean, other small states, metropolitan countries, and for the related policy and theoretical literature are considered.
Education policy priorities for the small states of the eastern Caribbean, with special reference to St Vincent and the Grenadines
George Bristol, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished MEd (2003)
This study examines the extent to which currently powerful international themes and agendas, promoted by the World Bank and other multi-lateral institutions, have impacted education policy priorities in the small nation-states of the Eastern Caribbean.
The study is conducted within the critical hermeneutics tradition and employs the method of documentary analysis in an intrinsic case study of St Vincent and the Grenadines. A theoretical framework, which is developed in chapter two, guides the study. It examines how the intensification of globalisation, combined with currently powerful agendas of multi-lateral developmental institutions, continue to create new and important challenges for education development in the Eastern Caribbean nation-states.
The study reveals that these small economies have turned to regionalisation and functional co-operation in an attempt to better prepare their citizens to take greater advantage of emerging global economic opportunities. Functional co-operation provides mechanisms through which many of the unique and often problematic features of these small nation-states (now aggravated by the intensification of globalisation), could be more adequately addressed. It also provides the platform from which OECS education reforms were initiated and co-ordinated, and through which the financial and technical assistance needed to realise the reforms were negotiated.
The analysis of the emerging education policy priorities, both at the local and sub-regional level reveal that, although the identification of these priorities benefits significantly from public inputs throughout the sub-region, they nonetheless show significant resemblance to many of the currently powerful themes promoted by development agencies such as the World Bank. The analyses also reveal that local and sub-regional education policy-makers adapted many of these themes to suit their particular educational and developmental needs. However, local and sub-regional education reforms were not limited to the narrow economic view of education promoted mainly by the World Bank. These reforms incorporated important cultural components into local and sub-regional educational provisions which were geared towards the empowerment of the ‘Ideal Caribbean Person’. Local adaptation of currently powerful global education themes and agendas is visible in the practice of educational policy-makers in St Vincent and the OECS, which demonstrates a strengthening of the existing dialectic of the global, the local and sub-regional.
Willy Yamuna Ako, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished EdD (2002)
This study investigates the policy-making and implementation of educational reforms in developing countries, and more specifically the nature and implementation of the 1993 Educational Reform in Papua New Guinea. The study focused on the achievements and problems of this reform in the light of praise, from both the government of Papua New Guinea and the international donor agencies, that contrasts with the criticism from local stakeholders, such as teachers, children and parents.
The empirical part of the study was conducted at the national and provincial education offices in Port Moresby and Mendi, and in two case study primary schools in the Southern Highlands Province of Papua New Guinea. Thirty key informants participated in the fieldwork. The research strategy is largely hermeneutic and interpretive in nature. It involved gathering, transcribing and interpreting data from a variety of sources, including document analysis, structured and unstructured interviews, observations and field notes.
The findings indicate that the reform initiative ‘mirrors’ the Jomtien Conference (1990) agendas and the aims of the Papua New Guinea Educational Sector Study (1991). Both the Conference and the Sector Study were initiated and sponsored by the donor agencies. The study reveals that the reform was largely centrally designed and the ability to fund it rests with the donor agencies. The input and resources of the donor agencies thus outweigh those of the Papua New Guinea government. It is argued that this resulted in the donor agencies being able to significantly influence the nature and implementation of the reform This reflects theoretical literature that suggests that donor agencies are too influential in research, policy-making and implementation concerning educational reforms in many developing countries. Data from the provincial and school levels in Papua New Guinea suggest that local personnel were not consulted with respect to the policy-making process. This has inhibited the effective implementation, practicality and ownership of the reform by the local people.
The management and leadership roles of Solomon Islands headteachers: perceptions, priorities and practices
Glynn Galo, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished EdD (2001)
The study examines the relevance of the international literature relating to school management and leadership for policy and practice in the Solomon Islands. This is done with reference to two detailed case studies of community high schools in the Solomon Islands. Detailed ethnographic fieldwork was carried out in these schools during 1999. Focus was placed on identifying headteachers’ perceptions, priorities and practices in the arena of management and leadership. Findings from the Solomon Islands’ fieldwork are compared and contrasted with key issues identified in the international literature.
Seven key themes emerged from the study and form the basis for the conclusions. These explore the implications of the study for: a) educational policy and practice in the Solomon Islands; and b) the critique of the related international literature. Above all, the study suggests that the uncritical international transfer of western management concepts and ideas can be wrought with much difficulty, if it is not anchored effectively enough to contextual realities and experiences. The dissertation also highlights the need for context specific headteacher training in the Solomon Islands; and for more relevant research of this nature to be conducted by local personnel if we are to better determine the needs of the headteachers in differing national and cultural contexts.
Thomas Kuli Webster, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished EdD (1997)
The study examines factors that have shaped policies for the universalisation of primary education in developing countries with specific reference to Papua New Guinea (PNG). It explores the premise that ideas generated in international policy research influence and shape the educational priorities of developing countries. A review of the related literature highlights the dominance of international donor agencies, particularly in directing the policy discourse that influences decisions on educational problems and possible solutions. It is argued that many such policy prescriptions are increasingly seen to be contextually irrelevant and do not reflect the priorities articulated in context. Nor can they be successfully implemented in the varying situations encountered. A case study of universal primary education (UPE) policy formulation in PNG is undertaken to analyse critically the extent of international and national influences in the light of the theoretical review.
The case study analysis focuses on three contexts of influence: the shaping of ideas; the production of policy texts; and the implementation of UPE policy. In the context of influence, the study examines how national and international influences have competed for dominance in PNG. In the second context, two key policy texts are analysed: the Education For all (EA) Plan, where an international consultant was engaged; and a more home-grown Education Sector Study. Finally, the context of practice is explored, largely through reflections on experiential knowledge, qualitative interviews with senior administrative officers from the PNG National Department of Education and three provincial education administrators, and a brief survey of provincial education administrators.
In the light of the PNG research, a reconsideration of the theoretical literature relating to the concepts of UPE and the effect on policy choices is carried out. A strong case is also made for the conduct and analysis of policy research in PNG and other developing countries.
Akhila Nand Sharma, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished EdD (1995)
In the light of the international literature on the educational change process and that relating more directly to vocational education and training in developing countries, this dissertation examines the management of the Fijian Vocational Education and Training Programme (VETP) in selected secondary schools. This is a two-year programme for early school-leavers and offers four courses: Automotive Engineering; Carpentry and Joinery; Tailoring, Food and Catering; and Secretarial Studies. The study addresses three key questions: a) what is the nature of the Fijian innovation; b) how does it relate to similar initiatives in other developing countries; and c) how are its initiation, implementation and institutionalisation processes being managed?
Theoretical and conceptual frameworks derived from the international literature on the management of planned educational change (Fullan 1991) are adopted for the Fijian study. This literature identifies three phases in the change process: initiation; implementation; and institutionalisation. Applying this framework for analysis, this investigation involves the study of change agents, users, the nature of innovation and internal and external environmental factors associated with the Fijian VETP.
The theoretical perspective that underpins the methodology and the data-collecting methods of this study is drawn from the phenomenological and qualitative case-study research literature. An attempt is made to understand the management of the Fijian VETP from the perspectives of those involved in it at the Ministry of Education headquarters and in two case-study schools. The data-collecting methods emphasise participant observation, in-depth interviewing and documentary analysis.
Based on the fieldwork findings, the study argues that: a) the VET innovation is regarded by its clients as a second best option to mainstream education and that it receives less attention by policy-practitioners and members of the school community. This is consistent with similar initiatives in many other developing countries; b) the successful implementation of an innovation depends largely on its characteristics; c) a Fijian secondary school context is not suitable for a separate stream of VET, although vocational education could be more effectively provided as a familiarisation programme in the mainstream secondary school curriculum; d) the relevant international literature is helpful in studying, understanding and improving the management of educational innovations, although its relevance for developing country context and their incorporation in this body of international literature would strengthen its relevance significantly; f) traditional ceremonies and practices, such as ‘talanoa’ and sevusevu’, can be gainfully employed to collect qualitative data in developing countries.
The study concludes by exploring various implications for Fijian educational policy-makers and practitioners and for the international literature on the management of education change. Areas for further research are also identified.
An evaluation of community involvement in the implementation of the Community Junior Secondary School Partnership Policy (CJSSPP): case studies in Botswana
Gabatshwane Taka Tsayang, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished EdD (1995)
This study is an evaluation of community involvement in the implementation of the Community Junior Secondary School Partnership Policy (CJSSPP) in Botswana. This is carried out in the light of the argument that once government becomes involved in locally initiated projects in Botswana, community interest wanes. The dissertation looks in detail at the experience of the six case study schools and argues that policy makers must better understand how policy is interpreted and implanted, if they are to improve their own potential to change educational practice.
The conceptual framework adopted for the study is drawn from a critical review of literature relating to community involvement in education in both developed and developing countries. Secondly, the methodological underpinning of the study is derived largely from comparative and international orientations to research that draws attention to the importance of detailed qualitative fieldwork, and the observation and analysis of educational practice in context. The study, therefore, documents various participants’ interpretation of the CJSSPP in six carefully selected community schools located in the Central District of Botswana
Data were primarily gathered through semi-structured, in-depth interviews; through detailed observations; and through the collection and analysis of relevant documentary evidence. The findings of this study reveal that while board of governor members had a poor understanding of the partnership policy (and this constrained implementation), the professionals and policy-makers did little to help them understand it. Evidence also indicated that, besides lay governor members, many professionals and policy-makers do not understand what is required for the success of their own policy in practice. The use of a talent bank, an obligatory contribution of resources by the community and the training of all those involved in the partnership are suggested as possible ways to improve understanding and the chances of successful implementation.
The study concludes by drawing attention to more general and theoretical issues that emerge from the Botswana experience, including the value that developing countries can derive from the increased use of qualitative approached in educational research.
Calliopa Pearlette Louisy, Graduate School of Education, University of Bristol - unpublished PhD (1993)
The expansion of tertiary education in small states is both problematic and controversial. On the one hand, the international literature on small states has generally portrayed them as being constrained by size, remoteness and dependence on external factors. Their economies have been regarded as open, constrained by a small internal market with limited demand for specialisation, and capable of sustaining only a small modern sector. This, and the small size of their populations has been used as the rationale for discouraging the development of national tertiary education sectors and for the regional provision of higher education in large groupings of small states. On the one hand, economic and political pressures are leading small states to challenge this received wisdom and to re-appraise their tertiary education capabilities. Policies aimed at strengthening national capacity have, thus, re-opened the debate about the credibility and viability of national tertiary level institutions.
In the light of the small-state literature, the thesis critically evaluates recent developments in tertiary education in the two largest groupings of small states – the Caribbean and the South Pacific. The study is based upon original fieldwork data collected for a detailed case study of the Sir Arthur Lewis Community College in St Lucia. A comparative analysis of tertiary provision in the non-campus territories served by the two regional universities – the University of the West Indies and the University of the South Pacific – supplements the case study data. The analysis identifies factors which have contributed to the establishment of national tertiary level institutions in both regions, and considers the policies that national authorities have adopted for the on-going expansion of in-country provision of tertiary education.
The thesis argues that the development of national tertiary education sectors is primarily motivated by issues of access, cost, control and human resource development needs. National responses to a wide range of local needs have thus resulted in a multi-level tertiary sector which has the potential to be both politically and economically viable. In both regions, parallel processes of centralisation and decentralisation are leading, on the one hand, to the establishment of national multi-purpose institutions, and, on the other, to a form of regional provision based on networks of mutually-supporting institutions. In what can be considered new responses to the challenge of scale, isolation and dependence, small states are consolidating provision at the national level, establishing mechanisms for harmonising policy and practice at the regional level and strengthening international linkages.