New radio series explores animal welfare and animal rights

What is the moral status of animals? This question is one that can polarise and divide and will be addressed in a unique way by Christine Nicol, Professor of Animal Welfare at the University of Bristol as part a four-part series called Would You Eat an Alien?, on BBC Radio 4 starting this week [Wednesday 9 December].

Professor Nicol will interview animal welfare scientists, philosophers and wildlife biologists to explore the question of whether animals have the ability to feel and the potential consequences of accepting that some animals are conscious, sentient creatures. 

To help consider the subject comedian Jake Yapp, will take on the role of a sensitive spaceman who has crash-landed on a remote planet.  He doesn’t have much food to keep him going until he is rescued. Fortunately, the planet is teeming with edible alien life forms but which ones should he eat?  He wants to cause the minimum amount of pain and distress to the creatures, so he needs to know whether they can feel pain, and how he can minimise suffering. 

However, as he discusses his dilemmas with Professor Nicol other questions emerge. Will eating one alien cause distress to others? Do some types of alien creatures have such a degree of self-awareness that Jake needs to consider whether they are non-human persons? And how does his own growing fondness for one particular individual affect his ultimate decision?

Professor Nicol from Bristol’s School of Veterinary Sciences and presenter on the series, said: “In this series, the biology of the alien creatures is central, and the different concerns of sentient animals, socially bonded animals and animals with some awareness of their own future are exposed for debate.”

The first programme in the series, Pain or no pain, will be broadcast on BBC Radio 4 at 9pm on Wednesday 9 December; followed by Emotional aliens on Wednesday 16 December; Living together on Wednesday 23 December and finally Alien persons on Wednesday 30 December.