Abstract:
In The Right to Sex (2021), Amia Srinivasan argues that a professor sleeping with a student constitutes a pedagogical failure – a failure to meet the responsibilities embedded in the student-teacher relationship. She challenges philosophers to think beyond consent and develop an ethics of pedagogy that attends to love in academia. This paper takes up that challenge, which I am uniquely placed to do, not only as a philosopher who teaches, but as someone who once loved my teacher: I had a relationship with a professor as a student, an experience of the “wrong sort of love” (Srinivasan, 2021) that I draw on directly rather than set aside. I argue that the question is not whether love belongs in the classroom, but what kind of love can resist, rather than reproduce, domination. Because love exists within social structures, it can entrench hierarchy and exploitation, but it can equally be a source of empowerment and transformation (García-Andrade et al., 2018; Gregoratto, 2025; Gunnarsson, 2018). This motivates the paper to develop a positive vision of the "right sort of love," a non-sexual, non-romantic love. Drawing on feminist philosophy, my own experience of the “wrong sort of love”, and two existing models of love in the academy, from Hypatia and bell hooks, I set out four commitments to underpin this love: redirection, boundaries, authenticity, and mutual transformation. These commitments do not resolve the ambivalence of love – but can help us to navigate the “love troubles” (Gregoratto, 2025). The “right sort of love,” then, should be seen as an ongoing, active pedagogical practice.
Bio:
Dr Alix Dietzel is a Senior Lecturer in Climate Justice at SPAIS, University of Bristol. Alix usually writes about just transition and climate ethics, and this paper is her first feminist philosophy piece. The paper has been motivated by Alix's experiences teaching feminist philosophy in her Philosopher Queens course and years of experience as a survivor advocate working on policy for regulating staff-student relationships in academia. The paper has received a R+R from Hypatia: A Journal of Feminist Philosophy.