Department Research Seminar - The Vices of Honesty

Abstract:
Recent work on honesty has resulted in some surprising claims about the vices associated with this virtue. First, both Miller (2021) and King (2021) argue there is no vice of excess associated with honesty, such that it is not possible to be too honest. Second, Battaly (2024) suggests that reflecting on dishonesty gives us reason to endorse normative contextualism – the view that the virtue status of traits changes depending on context. In this talk, I develop an account of the vices associated with honesty. I argue that a plausible understanding of these vices give us no reason to endorse either of the two surprising claims from the recent literature. However, reflecting on these traits does help to reveal a more fine-grained distinction between types of moral vice. This has implications for future work in virtue and vice theory, including practical implications for those engaged in character education.

All welcome!

Contact information

Seiriol Morgan - Seiriol.Morgan@bristol.ac.uk