Working paper 03/069 - Abstract

Commons as Insurance and the Welfare Impact of Privatization (PDF, file 12.6 KB) (PDF, 243kB)

Jean-Marie Baland and Patrick Francois

It is shown here that despite the efficiency gains from privatization, when markets are incomplete, all individuals may be made worse off by privatization, even when the resource is equitably privatized. Such market incompleteness is common in the developing world and can explain the often encountered resistance to efficiency enhancing privatizing reforms, especially in the case of village level landholdings and forests. The advantage of commonly held property arises because of its superior insurance properties (which tend to provide income maintenance in low states). Sufficient conditions are established under which any feasible insurance scheme under private property cannot ex ante Pareto dominate allocations under the commons.

Note: some of the documents on this page are in PDF format. In order to view a PDF you will need Adobe Acrobat Reader